| 2009 ACME Baseball Congress ALL Tournament Team |
| Keith Wenning |
| Nathan Cheney |
| Anthony DeThomas |
| Deon Tansel |
| Kenny Dixon |
| Titus Montgomery |
| Alex Nofziger |
| Kurt Belau |
| Dace Kime |
| Coldwater |
| Bluffton |
| Anthony Wayne |
| Anthony Wayne |
| Springfield |
| Springfield |
| Defiance |
| Defiance |
| Defiance |
| MVP |